Pulitzer prizewinning author philip roth penned the book the human stain about a college professor deemed a racist for an innocent comment he made in class one day, despite the characters. It is 1998, the year in which america is whipped into a frenzy o. Its first person narrator is 65 yearold author nathan zuckerman, who appeared in several earlier roth novels. The precise language has since been altered by wikipedias. Coleman silk has a secret, one which has been kept for fifty years from his wife, his four children, his colleagues, and his friends, including the writer nathan zuckerman. The human stain bears all the scars and stretch marks of a work that has tried to condense the necessarily literary elements of an esteemed novel into a feature film format. Ten years after someone first wrote a wikipedia entry for philip roths bestselling novel the human stain, published in 2000, the great author has discovered the latest entry and he is not happy. It is 1998, the year in which america is whipped into a frenzy of prurience by the impeachment of a president, and in a small new england town, an aging classics professor, coleman silk, is forced to retire when his colleagues decree that he is a racist.
While there is a central narrator, nathan zuckerman, through whose eyes and ears, we learn about the antihero coleman silk, there are different voices that make up. The human stain is a 2003 drama film directed by robert benton. Its screenplay, by nicholas meyer, is based on the novel of the same name by philip roth. In nathans case he wrote a scandalous book, was accused of being a. It is a worthy addition to american fiction of the early 21st century. The internet stain of a philip roth wikipedia entry the. Silk has asked him to write the true account of the witchhunt that has ruined his.
In what ways does the human stain resist this conventionalizing need for closure. Roths human stain in a long writing career, philip roth has progressively deepened his themes and his understanding of human character as well as his skill at the novelists craft. It was better when roth wrote it, semen references and all. Silk has asked him to write the true account of the. My novel the human stain was described in the entry as allegedly inspired by the life of the writer anatole broyard. The human stain is a book complex enough to be lastingly satisfying and has the sense of capturing a particular time in american history while also satirising small town college life and political correctness, approaching race and identity, and the male psyche to name but a few major themes. The stain you cant paint black and not get black, no matter how hard you try. The human stain is the final book in a loosely connected trilogy of novels about postwar america that roth has produced over the last four years. Theres no way we can contain the secret, and were not even trying to, the films producer, tom rosenberg, told me at the toronto film festival. Most movie characters are like greek gods and comic book heroes. The title of this book is human stain and it was written by philip roth. The human stain, 2000 at first glance the human stain might seem to be a story about political correctness and 1990s puritanism, michiko kakutani wrote. A reading of the human stain article pdf available in the cambridge quarterly 391.
It may sound odd to begin with the final book in a series, but the novel is a standalone one. Wikipedia told philip roth hes not credible source on book he wrote famed author tries to correct wikipedia article on human stain, gets rejected. Over a career that spanned almost 50 years, he wrote 31 books. The film stars anthony hopkins, nicole kidman, gary sinise and ed harris. Silk teaches at the same university which, we are told, once employed ei lonoff, the great jewish author whom nathan. I ever knew about broyardthat and what he wrote in. The human stain is a flawed but engrossing story about the way that people try to escape their pasts.
You may paint with care, but the stains are there, and stay when the paint is dry. How does it alter the classical unities of beginning, middle, and end. Observing silks estranged son mark in wild lamentation, nathan is less than generous in imagining what might be going on in the young mans head. The human stain 2000, which is the third novel in philip roths american trilogy, is the first of his books which i have read. Yes, we have to suspend disbelief over the casting, but thats easier since we can believe the stories of these people. Sign me up to get more news about literary fiction books. The human stain is a novel of identity that revolves around the love affair of two people who could not be more opposite. Not many movies probe into matters of identity or adaptation. One of those books where an aging author insertcollege professor rediscovers his penishimself by screwing a younger chick. The human stain has been directed by robert benton with a sure feel for the human values involved. Only those who have travelled in a country of hostile indians, pumpelly wrote, know what it is to journey by night.
Consider this odd passage in the human stain by philip roth. There are passages of such sustained brilliance here that i found myself going over. Reflecting on the deaths of coleman silk and faunia farley, nathan zuckerman who, like roth, is nowhere else given to philosophical obscurities writes, nothing lasts, and yet nothing passes, either. His story is told by nathan zuckerman, who has, literally speaking, been employed as narrator.
The human stain is a schizophrenic, if not unevenly written novel. Engl 291 lecture 21 philip roth, the human stain cont. In the turbulent summer of 1998 while the country reacts with prurient. The vietnam vet les farley is a menacing, violently angry character, whose streamofconsciousness rants reflect some of the most powerful writing in. We must remember that everything is shaded by what zuckerman knows and what he believes. The human stain chapter 5, the purifying ritual summary. The human stain pulses with the strengths that make roth a prime contender for the status of the most impressive novelist now writing in and about america, sunday times an extraordinary book bursting with rage, humming with ideas, full of dazzling sleights of hand, sunday telegraph one of his very best. I have always thought of it as a new way of looking at the holocaust. Philip roth unable to correct wikipedia entry on his own. There is the occasional bright spot, but mostly the book fulfills the titles purposethe human stain. You cant fool around where the sinners found, make friends of the foolish kind, but it leaves some taint, like the mark. His novel, the human stain is both entertaining and thoughtprovoking. In this final lecture on the human stain, professor hungerford argues that desire is the engine of narrative, for roth, both at the structural level and in the very grammar of his sentences. The human stain quotes showing of 101 the pleasure isnt in owning the person.
It is 1998, the year in which america is whipped into a frenzy of prurience by the. The charge is a lie, but the real truth about silk would have astonished his most virulent accuser. After a clunky beginning, in which crusty nathan zuckerman is carrying on about the orgy of sanctimoniousness surrounding. The human stain is an exploration into the nature of humans. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read the human stain. For the first third of the human stain i thought similarly, but as the book progressed, and the story didnt in any depth, i eventually grew weary of the world view and the overwriting, and skimmed to the end. This is where the novel begins, silk having struck up an unlikely friendship with. If youve never read philip roths books, heres where to. In the human stain, the narrator, nathan zuckerman, attends the funeral of a newish friend, coleman silk, a professor of greek at a small massachusetts college called athena. For the first third of the human stain i thought similarly, but as the book progressed, and the story didnt in any depth, i eventually grew weary of the world view. Confronting the failures of a professor who passes.
Quizlet flashcards, activities and games help you improve your grades. Sometimes clunky and overreaching, sometimes piercing and compassionate, philip roths vital new novel the human stain completes a postwar trilogy that includes 1997s vietnamera american pastoral and 1998s antimccarthy diatribe i married a communist. It is 1998, the year america is plunged into a frenzy of prurience by the. This is the pulitzer prizewinning writer philip roth at his very best. Its also about the way that carefully constructed new personas, no matter how scrubbed and burnished, cant erase the stain of the original. The human stain 2000 is a novel by philip roth that was published on may 5, 2000. I have just finished reading an excellent novel by philip roth called the human stain, a novel i had never heard of, written in late 90s, set in 1998 during the clinton scandals. The human stain by philip roth book club discussion. It is zuckerman who stumbles upon silks secret and sets out to reconstruct the unknown biography of this eminent, upright man. We have 1 answer for the clue the human stain novelist.
The charge is a lie, but the real truth about silk would have astonished even his most virulent accuser. The vietnam vet les farley is a menacing, violently angry character, whose streamofconsciousness rants reflect some of the most powerful writing in the book. The tragic mulatto is a stereotypical fictional character that appeared in american literature during the 19th and 20th centuries, from the 1840s. Content includes books from bestselling, midlist and debut authors. The human stain contains a significant secret about one of the characters. After a clunky beginning, in which crusty nathan zuckerman is carrying on about the orgy of sanctimoniousness surrounding clintons monica misadventures, his new novel settles into what would seem to be patented roth territory. I had been very impressed with american pastoral, with roths style of prose and his insight into his characters. The human stain explicitly recollects his first appearance in a roth novel. Philip roths pulitzerprize winning 1997 novel, american pastoral. Coleman silk is a classics professor, a man who was once well respected in his small community before an accusation took from him the identity he spent fifty years creating. The book is mostly dark but revealing about the dark side. The tragic mulatto is an archetypical mixedrace person a mulatto, who is assumed to be sad, or even suicidal, because they fail to completely fit in the white world or the black world. Roths extraordinary recent productivity the prizewinning sabbaths theater, 1995, and american pastoral, 1997 continues apace with this impressively replete and very moving chronicle of an academic scandal and its impact on both the aging professor at its center and his friendalter ego novelist nathan zuckerman. It is as though it is written by different people, with variable success.
638 7 1120 1169 1461 1206 548 618 1628 1438 275 893 5 1577 91 99 166 197 150 1065 695 194 1073 365 531 618 849 1231 193 807 630 375 844 1275 189 506 163 1490 468 443